return to 1880 Denver Index

Presbyterian Church

    The First Presbyterian Church of Denver was organized December 15, 1861, by Rev. A. S. Billingsley, acting under a commission from Board of Domestic Missions, Old School.  The services were held in International Hall, on Ferry street, West Denver, then known as "Auraria."  Eighteen members, of whom eleven were women, were enrolled.  Mr. Billingsley remained with the church but four months, until April, 1862, and then the little church was without a Pastor until the following November, when Rev. A. R. Day assumed the ministration, receiving his support is in part from the same Board of Missions.  Mr. Day at once commenced agitating the subject of a church edifice, with such success that he secured a donation from Maj. John S. Fillmore, Paymaster United States Army, of a lot 40x100 feet, on Fifteenth street, between Arapahoe and Lawrence.  Citizens of all classes and denominations contributed liberally for the erection of the church, the Home Mission Board contributed $500, and a brick structure, 37x65 feet, was commenced in 1863, and completed in 1865.  Mr. Day resigned in February, 1865, and again the pulpit was vacant for several months.  In the following October, Rev. J. B. McClure, of Fulton, Ill., became the Pastor, and continued in charge two years, when he resigned, and the pulpit was again vacant until March, 1868, when A. Y. Moore, of South Bend, Ind., became the Pastor.  Hitherto, the Old School Presbyterian Board of Missions had contributed to the support of the Pastor, but the Board becoming financially embarrassed it was unable to continue the contributions, and Mr. Moore was compelled to return to his home.  Failing to receive the necessary encouragement and assistance from the Old School Board, the Church opened negotiations with the New School Board, and extended a call to Rev. E. P. Wells, at the same time asking to be connected with the Presbytery of Chicago, through which the call to Mr. Wells was made.  On November 29, 1868, the Church was legally incorporated, and on Sunday evening, November 28, 1868, Mr. Wells was formally installed Pastor.  About this, [sic] time several members of the Church withdrew, and formed what is now known as the Seventeenth Street Presbyterian Church.  


pgs. 269-270